Resource records for a host in a zone file are included and their fully qualified domain name resides in another zone. The exception is a glue record or CNAME record supporting a system migration.

Overview

Finding ID	Version	Rule ID	IA Controls	Severity
V-4468	DNS0230	SV-4468r1_rule	ECSC-1	Low

Description
If a name server were able to claim authority for a resource record in a domain for which it was not authoritative, this would pose a security risk. In this environment, an adversary could use illicit control of a name server to impact IP address resolution beyond the scope of that name server (i.e., by claiming authority for records outside of that servers zones). Fortunately, all but the oldest versions of BIND and most other DNS implementations do not allow for this behavior. Nevertheless, the best way to eliminate this risk is to eliminate from the zone files any records for hosts in another zone. The two key exceptions to this rule involve glue for NS records and CNAME records for legacy resolution support

Description

If a name server were able to claim authority for a resource record in a domain for which it was not authoritative, this would pose a security risk. In this environment, an adversary could use illicit control of a name server to impact IP address resolution beyond the scope of that name server (i.e., by claiming authority for records outside of that servers zones). Fortunately, all but the oldest versions of BIND and most other DNS implementations do not allow for this behavior. Nevertheless, the best way to eliminate this risk is to eliminate from the zone files any records for hosts in another zone. The two key exceptions to this rule involve glue for NS records and CNAME records for legacy resolution support

STIG	Date
Windows DNS	2013-04-12

Details

Check Text ( C-3431r1_chk )
Review the zone files and confirm with the DNS administrator that the hosts defined in the zone files do not reside in another zone with its fully qualified domain name. If extraneous resource records are maintained, then this is a finding. BIND The zone file location can be found by examining the named.conf and searching for the zone statement. Within the zone statement will be a file option that will display the name of the zone file. Review the zone file and check for records that contain domain names outside of the zone. I.E. A zone named fso.chambersburg.com will not have a record for a host with a domain ending in disa.mil. Windows Open the DNS management snap in for the Administrative Tools menu. Expand the Forward Lookup Zones folder. Expand each zone and ensure the name column for each record does not contain a name for a record that resides outside of the zone. I.E. A zone named fso.chambersburg.com will not have a record for a host with a domain ending in disa.mil.

Check Text ( C-3431r1_chk )

Review the zone files and confirm with the DNS administrator that the hosts defined in the zone files do not reside in another zone with its fully qualified domain name. If extraneous resource records are maintained, then this is a finding.

BIND
The zone file location can be found by examining the named.conf and searching for the zone statement. Within the zone statement will be a file option that will display the name of the zone file. Review the zone file and check for records that contain domain names outside of the zone. I.E. A zone named fso.chambersburg.com will not have a record for a host with a domain ending in disa.mil.

Windows
Open the DNS management snap in for the Administrative Tools menu. Expand the Forward Lookup Zones folder. Expand each zone and ensure the name column for each record does not contain a name for a record that resides outside of the zone. I.E. A zone named fso.chambersburg.com will not have a record for a host with a domain ending in disa.mil.

Fix Text (F-4353r1_fix)
The DNS database administrator should remove any resource records for a host in a zone file if its fully qualified domain name resides in another zone, unless the record is a glue record or temporary CNAME record supporting a system migration.